Return to Main Menu
Alabama man gives kidney to stranger
Murrells Inlet resident met donor on Web
site where patients post their profiles
Post and Courier
About two years ago, Thomas Burns, a 50-year-old father of five from
Mobile, Ala., decided to give away his kidney. He was not aiming to
help a family member or a lifelong friend. He wanted to save a
Burns realized that wish at MUSC April 8, when surgeons removed one of
his kidneys and transplanted the organ into Dieter Illhardt, 70, of
The two met on MatchingDonors.com, a Web site where patients post their
profiles and potential donors search for a life they want to save.
Illhardt, a retiree with a sharp German accent, worked 40 years for
electronic manufacturing giant Siemens, laboring on large rotating
equipment and liquid ring vacuum pumps.
He suffers from diabetes and has been on dialysis for 11 months. “It is
hell. I cannot describe it,” Illhardt said of the blood-cleansing
treatments that can last for four hours or longer. Kidney failure
affects between 10 percent and 40 percent of people with diabetes.
The kidneys’ main function is to clear waste material from the blood.
The two organs also regulate salt and potassium and produce hormones
that affect blood pressure and red-blood cell production. A healthy
person should be able to live with one kidney, which will compensate
for the lost organ.
Illhardt’s wife could not donate her kidney because of her age, and
their daughter has diabetes, ruling her out.
“It means to get a new life,” Illhardt said of receiving a kidney.
“Being on dialysis, you’re not living.”
As for what drove Burns to donate part of his body, Illhardt shook his
head in amazement.
Burns, a 6-foot-4, 250-pound retired Army sergeant, looks as strong as
the trees he cuts for a living.
“The biggest trigger for me is seeing what kids watch on TV,” Burns
said. “They need to understand everything about life is not just about
money. You need to leave a footprint on Earth.”
Burns said it was important to him to know who got his kidney. When he
met the Illhardts, Burns said, “I was reminded of my mother and dad. I
felt something there.”
About two out of every five kidney transplants are from live donors,
according to the United Network for Organ Sharing, a national registry
that matches recipients with cadaver organs.
The network lists 675 people in South Carolina waiting for a kidney.
The average waiting time in the state is two to three years, although
146 patients have been waiting for five years or longer.
Usually, live donors are friends or family of the recipient. During the
past five years, sites such as MatchingDonors.com, which charge
recipients a subscription fee, have become more popular.
Kidneys from live donors are desirable because they are tested
thoroughly, and they last longer than kidneys from cadavers.
But some are skeptical of Internet matching. Arthur Caplan, Center for
Bioethics director at the University of Pennsylvania, compared the
pitfalls to Internet dating.
Participants might not be telling the truth about themselves, he said,
and relationships could turn manipulative. “Online tends to open the
door to an underground market,” he said.
Also, if more and more people trade organs via the Internet, the
traditional registry system might be eroded, bioethicists warn. The
United Network for Organ Sharing ranks potential recipients according
to objective medical criteria.
Dr. Kenneth Chavin, a specialist in transplant surgery who removed
Burns’ kidney, compared live organ donation to frequent blood donors.
“People, out of the goodness of their hearts, step forward.”
A couple of anonymous live donors have made themselves available
through the transplant program at MUSC. One was a father whose son
received a kidney from a deceased donor, said Dr. Prabhakar Baliga,
head of MUSC’s transplant surgery division.
As nurses and doctors prepared Burns for surgery Tuesday, he gave his
wife, Carla, a wink. The two clasped hands, and her chest fell in a
Donor and recipient were recovering during the afternoon following a
Editor’s note: The article ran April 9 in The Post and Courier and is
reprinted with permission.
‘Organs for Sale?
Thinking about Transplantation’ lecture to be held
The lecture, “Organs
for sale? Thinking about Transplantation,” will take place at 4 p.m.
April 21 in St. Luke’s Chapel (corner of Bee Street and Ashley Avenue).
Sponsored by the Caritas Fellowship, the lecture is open to the public
and will be given by Gilbert Meilaender, Ph.D.
Meilaender is the Duesenberg Professor of Christian Ethics at
Valparaiso University, a member of the President’s Council on Bioethics
since its inception, and a Fellow of the Hastings Center.
A prominent and influential bioethicist, Meilaender has had an
important role in advising the president and leading the public
conversation regarding the difficult matters of embryonic stem cell
research, human cloning and other topics arising from biomedical
Caritas, sponsored by the
Episcopal Church of the Holy Communion, meets at noon every Thursday on
the MUSC campus. For more information, call Fr. Patrick Allen 722-2024
or e-mail Patrick@caritasfellowship.org.
Friday, April 18, 2008
Catalyst Online is published weekly,
as needed and improved from time to time by the MUSC Office of Public
for the faculty, employees and students of the Medical University of
Carolina. Catalyst Online editor, Kim Draughn, can be reached at
or by email, firstname.lastname@example.org. Editorial copy can be submitted to
Online and to The Catalyst in print by fax, 792-6723, or by email to
email@example.com. To place an ad in The Catalyst hardcopy, call Island
Publications at 849-1778, ext. 201.